Sunday’s issue of The Cross Check Daily puts six lead stories side by side across Fox News, Al Jazeera, PBS NewsHour and other outlets. Each story shows what the reporting agrees on and where the framing differs, followed by a markets snapshot, a health item and a trivia question.
Democrat Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins won Alaska’s governor’s race.
Agree: Democrat Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins, a former state lawmaker from Sitka, has won Alaska’s governor’s race, Fox News reports, after the Associated Press called the race on Friday evening, Nov. 13. He defeated Republican Bernadette Wilson, the only candidate President Trump endorsed; Trump criticized two other Republicans in the race, Dave Bronson and Treg Taylor, for splitting conservative voters. Alaska uses ranked-choice voting, and outgoing Gov. Mike Dunleavy was barred from seeking a third consecutive term. (Fox News)
Spin check: We could read only two pieces in full. Fox News covered the win itself and put the weight on Republican infighting: it stressed Trump’s endorsement of Wilson, his criticism of two other Republicans for splitting conservative voters, and ranked-choice voting as a complication. It gave no vote totals or margin. PBS NewsHour ran a related Associated Press report on voters rejecting a repeal of ranked voting, citing supporters and opponents of the system. Headlines from NPR and CNN appeared in search results, but we could not open either page, so we cannot say how they framed it. We did not find a matching piece from Al Jazeera or Just Security.
Framing difference: Only one outlet that covered the win itself could be read, so we cannot say how others framed it. The two pages we read differ in emphasis (Republican infighting versus the ranked-voting ballot measure), and we found no conflicting figures.
Read: Fox News · PBS NewsHour
A federal judge temporarily blocked the closure and overhaul of East Potomac Golf Links in Washington.
Agree: U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes issued a two-week temporary restraining order on Saturday, delaying the planned closure of East Potomac Golf Links, a public course on federal land in Washington. The course was set to close Sunday for 15 months of renovation, a project Trump announced in May to prepare the course for major professional events. Plaintiffs say the changes would make the course unaffordable, which Trump denies, and Reyes cited Trump’s own posts as showing the National Park Service plan was final. (Fox News, with AP reporting)
Spin check: We could read only one piece on this story, from Fox News, which ran it in its sports section with Associated Press reporting. It centers on the judge’s order, Trump’s “Trash Island” post, and the claim that the plan is final. CNN and NPR both had pieces on this ruling in search results, but the pages could not be opened, so we cannot say how they framed it. We did not find a new piece from PBS, Al Jazeera or Just Security dated within the past two days.
Framing difference: We could read only one outlet on this ruling, so we cannot say how others framed it or whether any facts differ.
Read: Fox News
A tanker hit a docked river cruise boat in New Orleans, and 32 people were taken to hospitals with no deaths reported.
Agree: A tanker, the Atlantic Asphalt, struck the docked river cruise boat American Heritage on the Mississippi River in New Orleans on Friday, Nov. 13. Officials said 32 people were taken to hospitals, none with critical injuries, and no fatalities were reported. The Coast Guard said the tanker appeared to have had “some type of loss of steering,” though the exact cause is unknown. The cruise boat, operated by American Cruise Lines, flipped while people were being evacuated, and the National Transportation Safety Board planned to investigate. (PBS NewsHour, AP)
Spin check: Outlets differ on how many people were aboard. PBS NewsHour (AP) first said about 180, Al Jazeera said 129 passengers, and Fox News also said 129 passengers on Nov. 13 before citing the mayor for 191 aboard on Nov. 14. A later PBS piece says 197 passengers and crew. AP’s first report also attached the 520-foot length to the cruise boat, while Al Jazeera and the later PBS piece give it for the tanker. CNN and NPR pieces appeared in search results, but we could not open them. We did not find a Just Security piece.
Factual disagreement: Outlets gave different counts of people aboard (129 passengers, about 180, 191, 197). We use 191 aboard, the figure Fox attributes to the mayor, 32 taken to hospitals, and a 520-foot tanker as Al Jazeera and the later PBS piece report it.
Read: PBS NewsHour (AP) · Al Jazeera · Fox News
The Saudi-led coalition says it shot down two Houthi ballistic missiles aimed at Riyadh, a day after intercepting two suspected Houthi drones.
Agree: The Saudi-led coalition said its air defences intercepted and destroyed two ballistic missiles that the Houthis launched toward Riyadh early Sunday, according to coalition spokesperson Turki al-Maliki. He said on Saturday that two suspected Houthi drones were also intercepted in Riyadh and southern regions. Saudi authorities say at least 26 people have been killed in suspected Houthi drone and missile attacks in Saudi Arabia since September 23, and on Saturday the US Embassy in Riyadh urged “heightened vigilance” because of an increased threat of Houthi attacks. (Al Jazeera, with AFP)
Spin check: We could read only one piece on this story, so we cannot say how other outlets framed it. Al Jazeera reports the interceptions largely through the coalition’s account, then sets it beside rival claims: Yemeni government forces claim gains and hundreds of Houthi casualties, while the Houthis claim 72 coalition air strikes in 24 hours. It also cites 340,000 people displaced in Yemen since August. We did not find a piece on this story from Fox News, CNN, NPR or Just Security dated within the past two days. The PBS piece we opened covers Trump and Iran policy and does not mention the Riyadh interceptions.
Framing difference: Only one outlet’s piece on this story could be read. The figures in the Al Jazeera article are attributed to the coalition, the Yemeni government and the Houthis, and the Houthi and government claims have not been independently verified.
Read: Al Jazeera · PBS NewsHour (AP)
Zelenskyy says a new European security framework raised by the U.S. could benefit Putin.
Agree: Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said the United States has raised a possible new security framework for Europe as part of efforts to end the war in Ukraine. He warned that Moscow could use such talks to weaken NATO and reshape the continent’s borders, saying the idea “can be dangerous” and “should not be the main agenda.” He also said Washington asked, for the first time, whether Ukraine would withdraw from parts of the Donbas that Russia does not control if Kyiv joined NATO, and that Kyiv will not surrender territory. (PBS NewsHour, AP)
Spin check: We could open only two pieces on these remarks. PBS NewsHour (an AP story) leads with the framework idea and Zelenskyy’s warning that Moscow could use it to weaken NATO, then covers the Donbas question, prisoner exchange plans and a Starshield complaint. Al Jazeera covers the same remarks but leads with the Donbas and NATO trade-off, and adds his comment that he would put a comprehensive package to a national referendum. We could not open CNN, which appeared in search results with a headline about a land-for-NATO idea. The Just Security Early Edition of Nov. 13 covers related talks but predates these remarks. We did not find a Fox News or NPR piece on this exact story.
Framing difference: The two outlets we read report the same remarks without conflicting facts, but differ in emphasis: PBS and AP lead on the framework and its risk to NATO, while Al Jazeera leads on the Donbas and NATO trade-off.
Read: PBS NewsHour (AP) · Al Jazeera
Hamas says a Rafah brigade commander died in an Israeli air strike in Gaza, as Israel’s defense minister vows to keep up an “offensive policy”.
Agree: Hamas confirmed that Samir Abu Younis, commander of its Rafah brigade, was killed in an Israeli air strike on the al-Mawasi area of Khan Younis in southern Gaza on Saturday, according to Al Jazeera. Israel’s military and the Shin Bet said they had targeted “a senior Hamas military commander” in a drone strike, and Al Jazeera reported that the strike hit a tent sheltering displaced people and wounded two others. Separately, Defense Minister Israel Katz said Israel will continue its “offensive policy” in Gaza until the Strip is demilitarized and Hamas is gone. (Al Jazeera)
Spin check: We could read only one piece on this story, so we cannot say how other outlets framed it. Al Jazeera labeled the dead man a “senior Hamas commander” in its headline, but in the article itself the Israeli military and Shin Bet only said they “targeted” such a commander, and Hamas named him as its Rafah brigade commander. The same outlet’s live blog led with one person killed and two wounded and Katz’s “offensive policy” vow, and did not mention a commander. We did not find a Fox News, PBS or Just Security piece on this strike dated within the past two days. CNN and NPR had November 12 reports on a different strike, at a Gaza hospital, but we could not open either page.
Framing difference: We could read only Al Jazeera, so we cannot compare outlets. Within Al Jazeera, the article stresses the commander and the strike on a displaced-people tent, while its live blog stresses one death and Katz’s policy statement. The commander’s death is per Hamas and is not independently confirmed.
Read: Al Jazeera article · Al Jazeera live blog
Markets snapshot: stocks slip, bitcoin drops
- S&P 500: 7,561.67 (-0.4%)
- Dow Jones: 52,347.55 (+0.1%)
- Nasdaq Composite: 25,136.27 (-0.9%)
- Brent crude: $95.84 (+0.02%)
- Gold (spot, per oz): $3,883.11 (+0.05%)
- Bitcoin (BTC/USD): $64,119 (-6.03%)
Index figures are Friday, November 13 closes from an AP market report (AP via KRMG), with percentage changes as AP rounds them; US markets are closed on weekends, so these remain the latest closes. Brent’s $95.84 and +0.02% are the figures shown on a Trading Economics page dated November 13 and last updated Sunday, November 15; the page gives no time of day or contract month and says its prices come from OTC and CFD instruments, so this is a quote, not a confirmed settlement, and the Brent row is approximate. Stocks slipped in shaky trading as technology shares weighed on the market and Treasury yields rose. Even so, AP says it was the first winning week since early October, with the S&P 500 up 2.5%, the Dow up 2.1% and the Nasdaq up 2.3% for the week. Gold and Bitcoin figures come from Alpha Vantage daily data for November 13 (Gold) and November 14 (Bitcoin) and are calculated from the two most recent daily closes. Gold’s $3,883.11 (Friday’s close) compares with $3,881.01 the day before. Bitcoin trades every day: its $64,119 is the November 14 daily close (UTC) returned by Alpha Vantage, compared with $68,237 on November 13, and the November 15 UTC day was still in progress when we checked.
Health & Longevity: olive oil and lower mortality risk
The finding: In two long-running U.S. cohorts (60,582 women and 31,801 men, all free of cardiovascular disease and cancer at the start), people who used more than 7 grams a day of olive oil had about a 19% lower risk of total and cardiovascular mortality, 17% lower cancer mortality, 29% lower neurodegenerative mortality and 18% lower respiratory mortality than people who never or rarely used it.
The source: Guasch-Ferré et al., Journal of the American College of Cardiology, January 2022
Do this today: Swap one of the fats you cook with or spread, such as butter, margarine or mayonnaise, for olive oil. The higher-intake group used more than 7 grams a day, which is roughly half a tablespoon by our conversion.
Worth knowing: This is an observational study, so it cannot prove olive oil caused the lower risk, and the Harvard summary we read does not list the study’s limitations. Replacing animal fats such as butter, margarine, mayonnaise or dairy fat with olive oil was linked to lower mortality, but the release reports no significant benefit when olive oil was compared with other vegetable oils. The funding came from National Institutes of Health grants, and the summary we read states no conflicts of interest. This newsletter isn’t written by a medical professional and isn’t a substitute for advice from your doctor, so check with your doctor before making big changes to your diet.
World Trivia
Alaska, whose new governor is in today’s news, was bought by the United States from Russia in 1867. About how much did the United States pay: $720,000, $7.2 million, or $72 million?
Reveal the answer
$7.2 million. According to the U.S. State Department’s Office of the Historian, Secretary of State William Seward agreed to a proposal from Russian Minister Edouard de Stoeckl to purchase Alaska for $7.2 million.
Edited and published by Randy Wardle. Get The Cross Check Daily free every morning, or follow @GetCrossCheck on X. See the full archive of past issues and our corrections policy.
